Thiscategorycomprisessevenorgansfrombefore therevolutionwhichhavebeenrestoredinthe19th centuryandwhichhavenotbeensubstantially modifiedinthe20thcentury,amongwhichtwoof thefinestorgansofParis:SaintRochandSaint Sulpice.AlthoughbothrebuiltbyCavaillé-Coll,their characteristotallydifferent.SaintRochhas preserveditsFrenchclassicalGrandJeuforagreat deal,comparablewiththeorganatSaintLouisde Versailles.ThesamecanbesaidoftheorgansatSt-Germain-de-l'AuxerroisandSaintLaurent.The organofStMédardhasbeenrebuiltbytheStoltz brothers and is basically a 19th century instrument. The(veryinteresting)organatSaintLieu-Saint Gillesissilentforyears,whiletheorganatSaint PierredeMontmartrecontainsnostopsfrom before the revolution, only its case survived.
The table summarizes the main characteristics of the seven organs from before the revolution which have been restored in the 19th century and which have not been substantially modified in the 20th century. With the exception of the organ of Saint-Médard (which is basically a Stoltz-organ) and the organ of Saint-Pierre-de-Montmartre (no stops at all from before the revolution), the percentage of old stops is 50% or more for all organs.
Organs of Paris
Before the revolution - Organs rebuilt in
the 19th century
Thiscategorycomprisessevenorgansfrombeforethe revolutionwhichhavebeenrestoredinthe19thcentury andwhichhavenotbeensubstantiallymodifiedinthe 20thcentury,amongwhichtwoofthefinestorgansof Paris:SaintRochandSaintSulpice.Althoughbothrebuilt byCavaillé-Coll,theircharacteristotallydifferent.Saint RochhaspreserveditsFrenchclassicalGrandJeufora greatdeal,comparablewiththeorganatSaintLouisde Versailles.ThesamecanbesaidoftheorgansatSt-Germain-de-l'AuxerroisandSaintLaurent.Theorganof StMédardhasbeenrebuiltbytheStoltzbrothersandis basically a 19th century instrument. The(veryinteresting)organatSaintLieu-SaintGillesis silentforyears,whiletheorganatSaintPierrede Montmartrecontainsnostopsfrombeforethe revolution, only its case survived. Saint-Germain-de-l'AuxerroisSain-LaurentSaint-Lieu-Saint-GillesSaint-Médard Saint-Pierre-de-MontmartreSaint-RochSaint-SulpiceSaint Louis de Versailles
The table summarizes the main characteristics of the seven organs from before the revolution which have been restored in the 19th century and which have not been substantially modified in the 20th century. With the exception of the organ of Saint-Médard (which is basically a Stoltz-organ) and the organ of Saint-Pierre-de-Montmartre (no stops at all from before the revolution), the percentage of old stops is 50% or more for all organs.